I think elwood54 makes a good suggestion. Since this is a NYC-focused site, it makes the most sense to first build out the information for local climbing spots first, then add details for spots out of town. Your "initial thoughts" list looks solid to me. The additional details you mention would be nice to have, but for me personally, the most important information is accurate descriptions of exactly where the climbs are, and how to get to them. Obviously, pictures and accurate Google maps help with this.
On that note, I live a few blocks south of Ft. Tryon park, and would be happy to meet up with someone to start mapping out the climbable features in the area, as well as in Inwood Hill Park a little to the north. For example, there is a rather obvious overhanging promontory in the woods in Ft. Tryon that often has chalk marks on it. Someone who is a better boulderer than I am could help figure out what the problems and their ratings are, since to me they're all frickin hard.
I think elwood54 makes a
I think elwood54 makes a good suggestion. Since this is a NYC-focused site, it makes the most sense to first build out the information for local climbing spots first, then add details for spots out of town. Your "initial thoughts" list looks solid to me. The additional details you mention would be nice to have, but for me personally, the most important information is accurate descriptions of exactly where the climbs are, and how to get to them. Obviously, pictures and accurate Google maps help with this.
On that note, I live a few blocks south of Ft. Tryon park, and would be happy to meet up with someone to start mapping out the climbable features in the area, as well as in Inwood Hill Park a little to the north. For example, there is a rather obvious overhanging promontory in the woods in Ft. Tryon that often has chalk marks on it. Someone who is a better boulderer than I am could help figure out what the problems and their ratings are, since to me they're all frickin hard.